FRACTURE, EXPEL, HUMILIATE a little-touted UN report points to Israel’s crimes against humanity

Palestinians living in the al-Dawa neighborhood north of Nuseirat Refugee Camp flee their homes once again this week after the Israeli army advances beyond the Yellow Line established under the ceasefire agreement in the central Gaza Strip. / Photo by Hassan Jedi/Anadolu via Getty Images.

I’m going to pull rank here as the punk freelance reporter who first told the world of the 1968 My Lai massacre in South Vietnam and then wrote two books, with the war still raging, full of explicit details of my fellow American GIs’ murders and sexual abuse that went on at the direction of the unit’s immediate officers, as two generals and one colonel, in aircraft, were observing the horrors below. Those atrocities were highlighted in a recent documentary about my career that Netflix financed, distributed, and is still streaming. The US media did not back off on its reporting on My Lai and other atrocities over the years that followed my reporting, even after US combat wound down in Vietnam in 1973.

Compare the treatment of that story to the very slight Western media coverage of the most recent United Nations report about the continuing horror show in still beleaguered Gaza and in parts of the increasingly brutalized West Bank. The report was conducted by an independent international commission under the guidance of the United Nations and is the third in a series that has studied the actions—amounting, it says, to “genocide” in Gaza—of the Israel Defense Forces in support of a government policy toward Arabs of “maximum land with minimum population” that has been in effect since Israel was recognized by the United Nations as a state in 1948.

The October UN report essentially restates its bitter complaints about the continuing military action of the IDF in Gaza and uses similar language in its denunciation of Israeli policy in the West Bank. It finds that the escalating actions of the Israeli military in the West Bank are part of “a widespread and systematic attack against the civilian population. The attack requires a high level of coordination and organised planning, indicating the existence of a policy [by the Israeli government] to attack the civilian population.”

The report says that Israeli soldiers and settlers in the West Bank are working hand in hand “in a pattern of collective punishment”—a phrase with special meaning for Jews since World War II—“to fracture, expel, humiliate, and subjugate the Palestine population in its entirety.” The report finds that the targeting of children by Israeli settlers and soldiers in the West Bank “is deliberate” and intended to be part of the attack against the broader Arab population in the West Bank.

The report finds that in cases it investigated that senior authorities in Israel and the IDF understood and agreed that settler violence amounted to a policy of “extermination”—another word with special meaning in Israel—against the civilian population of the West Bank since October 7, 2023—the date of the infamous Hamas attack inside Israel.

The UN report states that investigated cases of torture, reproductive violence, rape, and other forms of sexual violence “were not isolated incidents . . . these acts form part of the broader attack” against the Arab population of the West Bank and were directly supported by the IDF as well as by the religious extremists in the political leadership of Israel. As such, the commission says, they are crimes against humanity.

One focus of the report is on the repeated use of sexual violence by settlers and the IDF in its attacks on Arabs in the West Bank. “Sexual violence,” the report says, “has been used to displace, subjugate, and destabilize the Palestinian people by humiliating and punishing on individual and collective levels” that amount to torture. “People of all genders, age, and sexual orientations have been targeted for being Palestinians or due to their . . . support for the rights of Palestinians.”

The commission concludes that Israel, as an occupying power, fails to ensure that the Palestinian population enjoys respect for their persons, honour, and family. It also fails to ensure that persons protected in law are protected in fact and treated humanely. Israel breached international human rights law by neglecting to prevent foreseeable harm to Palestinians, including women and children, while refusing to “prosecute or sanction IDF perpetrators of such egregious violence and to provide needed remedies for victims.”

The commission’s report backs up these assertions by including graphic accounts of extreme sexual abuse of Palestinians by members of the IDF who took pleasure in gang rape, physical abuse of genitals, and violent cavity searches of both men and women without, as the report says, any “apparent security justification.” Photographing the worst of such incidents was prevalent, the report noted. Similar treatment was given to pregnant Palestinian women who were detained.

I have elaborated on the UN report because, so I thought, there was a lot to be written about it. Yes, it’s just another in a seemingly unending series of United Nations reports that are immediately denounced by Israel authorities. But this report just did not cut it with the major US media, outside of a summary dispatch in the New York Times and an Associated Press article that included details of sexual abuse of prisoners along with heated denials by Israeli authorities.

I couldn’t help thinking that the American media did a hell of a lot better with the My Lai story, which came amid another ongoing war. We Americans have become numb to bad government and brutal wars.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *